Fabric softener vs. detergent: What’s the best for laundry?

When it comes to laundry day, the choice between fabric softener vs. detergent is a topic of endless debate. Should you prioritize cleaning or softening? Is there a secret to achieving perfectly laundered clothes?

With so many products on the market, it’s easy to get tangled up in choices. This guide aims to unravel this knotty question and give you all you need to know.

By comparing the two, you'll be able to decide which product or combination best suits your laundry routine. After all, everyone deserves fresh, clean, and soft clothes, right?

What is a fabric softener? 

When you pull a shirt from the dryer, and it feels like wearing a cloud, that’s your fabric softener or fabric conditioner (as some people call it) working its magic. This fancy laundry add-on is a game-changer for keeping your clothes soft, cozy, and smelling fresh.

A fabric conditioner and softener’s goal is to condition your clothes and make them feel as good as they look. They coat the fibers of your clothes to reduce friction during the wash and rinse cycle. This results in softer clothes, which means your threads will less likely stretch, fade, or get those pesky static shocks. In simpler terms, using a fabric softener gives your clothes and linens that extra bit of TLC.

What is a detergent? 

Detergents are the ones in charge of getting rid of the dirt and stains on clothes. Whether it’s a bio or non-bio laundry detergent, each has its own unique way of tackling the grime depending on its ingredients and chemical composition. Bio detergents use enzymes to break down proteins, fats, and starches. On the other hand, non-bio detergents are kinder to sensitive skin as they opt for a more gentle approach to cleaning.

There are also powder and liquid detergents. Powder detergents are great for heavy-duty cleaning, while liquid detergents are better for pre-treating stains and getting into tight spots like collars and cuffs.

No matter what you’re dealing with, there’s a detergent out there ready to rescue your clothes and make them look as good as new. You just need to throw your laundry into the machine with a good detergent, and you’re all set.

Fabric conditioner vs. detergent: What are their key differences?

When it comes down to laundry day or stocking up your stylish new laundry area, taking your pick between a detergent and a fabric conditioner or softener will surely stop you in your tracks. But you don’t have to stay wondering for long. This guide will break down their differences and when to use which.  

In terms of cleaning power

Fabric softener and detergent serve distinctly different purposes in the laundry process. While a detergent’s job is to remove dirt and stains from your clothes, fabric softener doesn’t contribute to the cleaning. Instead, it softens fabrics and reduces static, so your clothes feel more comfortable against your skin.

Now, you might wonder, does fabric softener clean clothes? The answer’s a straightforward no. It’s the detergents that tackle the tough spots and grime, whether you’re using top-load or front-load washers. These machines differ in their mechanism, but the underlying fact remains the same – detergent cleans and fabric softener softens. 

In terms of fabric softness

When it comes to making your clothes feel softer, the fabric softener stands out. As a cloth conditioner, it enhances the fabric feel and makes each garment more comfortable. You’ll find that after using them, your clothes not only smell fresh but also have that luxurious, soft touch.

However, it’s crucial to know that not all laundry softeners are created equal. Some might leave a residue that affects fabric breathability, especially in sportswear and moisture-wicking fabrics. That’s why exploring other choices is highly beneficial. There are products specifically designed to maintain softness without compromising the fabric’s functionality.

Detergents, on the other hand, don’t have any effect on fabric softness. They’re solely responsible for eliminating dirt, grease, and other stains. There are some variants that might claim to have softening properties, but they’re not as effective as fabric softeners. 

In terms of fragrance

Fragrance plays a major role in our laundry routine. Surely, many of us prefer clothes that smell as clean as they look. 

Luckily, detergents often come packed with a variety of scents, from fresh linen to tropical breezes. The intensity and longevity of the fragrance can vary greatly between products, but detergents only offer a subtle scent that fades quickly.

Meanwhile, certain fabric softners are formulated to keep your garments smelling fresher for longer. It’s worth experimenting with different brands and types to find the perfect match for your nose and wardrobe. 

In terms of color protection

Nobody wants their favorite red sweater to turn pink or their crisp white shirts to become dull. That’s why it’s important to know that detergents are great at removing dirt, but they don’t specifically protect colors.

Some washing laundry liquid formulas boast color-protecting agents aimed at keeping your vibrant hues as dazzling as the day you bought them. However, it’s the fabric softeners that indeed prevent colors from fading. They contain ingredients that coat the fibers and protect them from harsh chemicals in the washing machine. 

In terms of fabric longevity

It’s a long-standing belief that using laundry detergent for washing machines affects the quality and longevity of your clothes. This is partly true since harsh chemicals in some detergents can damage delicate fabrics like silk or wool. But, overall, the main factor that affects fabric wear and tear is the washing machine itself.

However, if you’re still worried, know that fabric softeners can extend fabric life. They make clothes softer and prevent them from wearing down too quickly by reducing friction during the wash cycle. They also guard against the rough and tumble of washing. 

In terms of cost

In your grocery runs, you’ll find that detergents generally come with a higher price tag. That’s because they’re tasked with the heavier job of removing dirt and stains from your clothes. On the flip side, fabric softeners, while beneficial for preserving fabric quality and color vibrancy, are often seen as an optional extra.

The price range for liquid fabric softeners spans from $3.74 for a basic 40 fl oz bottle to $11.97 for larger, 140 fl oz ones. There are also dryer sheets priced at $6.97 for a 200-pc box.

In contrast, the price range for liquid laundry detergents is between $6.00 to $109.00. For those preferring powder detergents or the convenience of pods, the price ranges from $10.94 to $22.94. 

Streamline your laundry routine with Airtasker

Your laundry routine doesn't have to be a chore that you dread every week. With Airtasker, you can easily find professionals who specialize in cleaning and laundry services.

Whether you're swamped with work or simply prefer to spend your free time doing things you love, posting your task on the platform connects you with skilled Taskers ready to tackle your laundry pile with the expertise it deserves.

You'll get the freedom to focus on what matters most to you, all while ensuring your clothes receive the best care.