Steam cleaner vs. carpet cleaner - a person using a carpet cleaner to clean a beige carpet

Steam cleaner vs. carpet cleaner: Which is more effective?

Comparing steam cleaners and carpet cleaners based on deep cleaning, drying time, cost, and more.

Hire an expert carpet cleaner

Published on

Key Facts

  • A steam cleaner is a cleaning device that uses hot steam to deep clean and sanitize various surfaces without the need for harsh chemicals.
  • A carpet cleaner is specially designed to clean carpets and rugs using water and carpet cleaning solutions.

When it comes to keeping our homes clean and healthy, the carpet is often left on the back burner. The common logic is that it's on the floor, so it's okay to get a little dirty. It's only supposed to be cleaned when there are visitors coming over, isn't it? Well, according to the American Lung Association, that's not a good strategy after all.

Carpets and rugs are perfect breeding grounds for dust mites and bacteria. They can even trap pollutants such as toxic gases and pet dander. That's why spending extra time choosing between steam cleaner vs. carpet cleaner isn't such a bad idea. Choosing the right cleaning method protects not only the lifespan of our carpets but, more importantly, the health of our families.

Fortunately, this comparison guide will arm you with the information you need to make the best choice for your home and health. Whether you're dealing with occasional spills or heavily soiled carpets, read on to find out which cleaning method is more effective for your needs.

What is a steam cleaner? 

Steam cleaner vs carpet cleaner - a person cleaning the carpet with a steam cleaner

Ever heard of using steam to get your carpet spotless? That’s exactly what a steam cleaner does. It’s like giving your carpet a hot shower without all the water mess.

Steam penetrates the fibers of your carpet, breaking down dirt, dust mites, and all those nasties that love to hide deep down where your vacuum can’t reach. Unlike shampooing, which can leave your carpets damp and take ages to dry, steam cleaning gets right to the heart of the grime without soaking the pad underneath.

And the best part? It doesn’t rely on chemicals, so it’s a friendlier choice for the environment and anyone in your home who’s sensitive to allergens. So, when you’re weighing steam cleaning carpets vs. shampooing, remember that carpet steam cleaners can give your space a deep clean and freshen up your home without adding extra pollutants.

What is a carpet cleaner? 

Steam cleaner vs carpet cleaner - a close-up of a person using a carpet cleaner to clean a dirty carpet

An electric carpet cleaner collects surface dirt while also applying a cleaning solution to your carpet to loosen up all the grime. Then, it sucks up the solution along with the dirt. It’s a more traditional approach compared to steam cleaning, but don’t think it’s any less effective.

The key features are the brush and suction power. The electric carpet cleaner works its magic by physically agitating the carpet fibers to scrub away stubborn stains. And yes, it does use water and detergent, but modern machines are designed to extract a significant amount of moisture, so drying time isn’t as long as you might think.

It’s an excellent choice for tackling those tough stains and giving your carpets a bit of TLC. Just remember, while it’s a powerful tool, choosing the right detergent is crucial—especially if you’re mindful about keeping things eco-friendly and safe for your family.

Carpet cleaner vs. steam cleaner: What’s the difference? 

When it comes to keeping your carpets clean and fresh, the choice between a carpet cleaner and a steamer might seem a bit daunting. But don’t worry, we’re here to break it down for you. 

We’ll look at the nitty-gritty of each method, from how they tackle dirt and stains to their environmental footprint. So that whether you’re dealing with a muddy mess or just giving your room a refresh, you’ll understand the pros and cons that will make all the difference. 

In terms of cleaning method

Steam cleaner vs carpet cleaner - a person using a steam cleaner to sanitize a floor carpet

A steam cleaner takes a different approach from traditional carpet cleaners. They heat water to produce steam, which then penetrates deep into the carpet fibers to break down dirt and grime. The heat alone is often enough to dislodge tough stains, so it’s usable for deep-cleaning jobs without needing detergents.

On the flip side, carpet cleaners excel in removing soiled stains and residue. These devices typically use a mixture of water and cleaning solution to treat stains directly and can be a lifesaver for quick clean-ups. You can even buy a handheld carpet washer that tackles specific spots, which is perfect for homes with pets or children.

Steam cleaners have the edge in terms of sanitation, though. This is because they can kill germs and bacteria with high-temperature steam. Carpet cleaners, however, rely heavily on the cleaning solution used for disinfection. 

Recommendation: Choose carpet cleaners to remove soiled stains and residue. But, if you’re looking for hygienic yet safe carpet cleaning, a steam cleaner might be the better option.

In terms of deep cleaning

Steam cleaner vs carpet cleaner - a close up of a cleaner to deep clean a carpet

Deep-clean carpet cleaners are designed to tackle the dirt that’s deeply embedded in your carpet fibers and that regular cordless and corded vacuums often miss. You just mix water and detergent, then use the machine to scrub the carpet before sucking the dirty water back into the machine.

On the other hand, does a steam cleaning carpet remove stains? The answer’s yes, and quite effectively at that. Steam cleaners use hot water vapor to penetrate carpet fibers and break down dirt without the need for chemicals. This method not only removes visible stains but also sanitizes them, making it a double threat against grime. 

Recommendation: Both carpet cleaners can be used for deep cleaning. But, if you’re aiming for a combo of deep cleaning and germ-busting without the need for chemicals, opt for a steam cleaner.

In terms of drying time

Steam cleaner vs carpet cleaner - a close up of a steam cleaner effectively cleaning a dirty gray carpet

When it comes to drying time, steam cleaners are better than carpet cleaners due to their method of using heat and minimal moisture. When you steam clean a rug, it might feel like your carpet will be wet for days, but it’s quite the opposite. The heat helps evaporate the moisture quickly.

In contrast, carpet cleaners soak the fabric more deeply with water and cleaning solution, leading to longer drying times. They’re great for a deep clean but think twice if you need a quick turnaround. 

Recommendation: Steam cleaning is your best bet for hassle-free carpet cleaning with quicker drying time.

In terms of versatility

Steam cleaners don’t just clean carpets but can also be used on hard floors, upholstery, and even garments. You can also use them to clean a spill of something like red wine or coffee or remove lingering odour from vomit. A steam cleaner’s ability to sanitise surfaces also makes it invaluable.

On the flip side, carpet cleaners are more specialized in their function. They’re your go-to for heavy-duty cleaning, but when it comes to other surfaces or different types of cleaning jobs, they’re not as adaptable as steam cleaners.

This means if you’re looking for a tool that’ll tackle a wide range of cleaning tasks beyond just carpets, a steam cleaner is your best friend. It’s especially handy in households with different types of flooring and fabric. Carpet cleaners, while powerful, are more of a one-trick pony but do that trick exceedingly well. 

Recommendation: You can't go wrong with a steam cleaner for a one-stop cleaning solution that’s as versatile as it gets.

In terms of safety

Steam cleaner vs carpet cleaner - cleaning and foaming a blue carpet

Steam cleaners have a distinct edge when it comes to safety because they use heated water to create steam instead of using chemicals. This makes them a safer choice, particularly in homes with kids or pets who might be sensitive to cleaning solutions. Just make sure to be extra cautious with the hot steam to prevent burns, but overall, they offer a non-toxic way to sanitize your space.

Carpet cleaners, on the other hand, typically rely on chemical cleaning solutions to break down dirt and stains. These substances can be harsh and might leave behind residues that irritate sensitive skin. Plus, the wet environment created by a carpet cleaner can be a breeding ground for mold or mildew if the area isn’t properly ventilated or dried. 

Recommendation: Steam cleaners are safer options because they don’t use harsh chemicals to clean. However, you still need to be careful when handling it while it is hot.

In terms of cost

Steam cleaner vs carpet cleaner - a person holding a carpet cleaner in a department store

When purchasing a cleaning tool, cost is always a factor to consider. Carpet cleaners tend to be more expensive than steam cleaners, especially if you opt for a high-end model with advanced features. Basic models can cost $50, while professional-quality variants can cost as high as $600. However, they often have a longer lifespan and can handle tougher cleaning jobs.

On the other hand, steam cleaners are generally more affordable and have lower operating costs since they don't require costly cleaning solutions. You can get budget-friendly brands for $88, while high-end commercial units can be sold for up to $6,500. They also have multiple attachments that allow them to clean different surfaces and fabrics effectively.

Alternatively, you can resort to professional carpet cleaning services, ranging from $50 to $1,000, for when you only need a deep clean once or twice a year. This option can be more cost-effective in the long run, as you won't have to invest in expensive cleaning tools and take up storage space. 

Recommendation: If you’re on a tight budget, a steam cleaner is the way to go. However, if you have tougher stains or need a machine that will last longer, investing in a carpet cleaner might be worth it.

Free yourself from carpet cleaning worries with Airtasker

Whether you're battling against the everyday wear and tear of your carpets or just aiming for that fresh, clean look and feel—remember you've got options. And sometimes, the best choice is to let the pros take over.

By posting your carpet cleaning or housekeeping task on the Airtasker platform, you’re making sure it gets done by skilled pros who know their way around even the toughest stains. It’s all about making your life easier and freeing up your time for what really matters.

Post a task today and connect with experienced Taskers eager to make your carpets look and feel as good as new. Sit back and get a clean home without the hassle. 

Steam cleaner vs. carpet cleaner

Steam Cleaner
Carpet Cleaner
Cleaning Method
Uses hot steam to penetrate and clean fibers
Uses water and cleaning solutions to clean
Deep Cleaning
Effective at sanitizing and removing stains
Excels at removing deep and soiled stains
Drying Time
Minimal moisture use leads to quicker drying time
Longer drying time due to water use
Can be used on various surfaces beyond carpets
Primarily designed for carpets and upholstery only
No chemicals; safer for sensitive environments
Uses chemicals; requires careful usage
Generally more affordable and lower operating costs
Tends to be more expensive with higher operating costs

FAQs on steam cleaners and carpet cleaners

The most effective carpet cleaning method is steam cleaning, also known as hot water extraction. It deeply penetrates carpet fibres to remove dirt, stains, and allergens effectively.

When you steam clean a carpet, the dirt is dissolved by the hot water and then extracted along with the water by the machine.

Steam cleaning uses hot water to remove dirt and stains, so it offers a deeper clean than dry cleaning methods. The latter are more surface-level but faster since it requires less drying time.

A steam cleaner is generally considered more effective than a steam carpet shampooer. It penetrates deeper into carpet fibers to remove dirt and allergens without leaving residue.

Avoid using steam cleaners to remove blood from a carpet, as they might actually set the stain. The quickest way to do so is to mix cold water with mild dishwashing detergent. Apply the mixture to the stain, then blot with a clean cloth.

Related articles

Related price pages

Find cleaning services, fast

Post a task