Keysmith vs. locksmith: Which professional should you call?

Getting the wrong person for a lock or key job can cost you time and money. Knowing whether to hire a keysmith or a locksmith ensures the work’s done right the first time. Here, we’ll outline what each professional does, the services they provide, and how to decide which one fits your needs.

What is a keysmith?

Rows of metal keys prepared for cutting at a professional locksmith station (Source: iStock)

A keysmith is a tradesperson who works specifically with physical keys. The role traditionally involves making, duplicating, or crafting keys from scratch using various techniques. Keysmithing has long been part of the hardware and security industry, particularly in retail or kiosk settings. Today, it remains an essential service for basic key creation and replacement.

What is a locksmith? 

Assorted keys and a door lock cylinder arranged for locksmith repair or installation (Source: iStock)

A locksmith is a trained professional who secures physical access points. This includes understanding the mechanics and systems behind locks, safes, and access controls. The locksmithing trade dates back centuries and has evolved to include modern practices in security, safety, and property access management across residential, commercial, and automotive industries.

Locksmith or keysmith: Who is the right person to hire?

Now that you know what each profession is, it’s time to explore how their skills, tools, and services differ in practice. The sections below will help you pinpoint who to call based on the job at hand—whether it’s a quick key copy or a full security upgrade.

In terms of services offered

Locksmiths provide various services, including installing and rekeying door locks, setting up digital or smart locking systems, duplicating high-security keys, and configuring access control for homes, offices, and vehicles. They also work with safes, keyless entry systems, and specialty locks for windows, gates, or commercial properties. Some locksmiths offer security consultations to recommend upgrades or replacements based on risk assessment.

Keysmiths offer key-focused services, primarily duplicating standard keys or cutting replacements from impressions. Their work is ideal for basic key needs such as creating spares for doors, padlocks, or filing cabinets. Their service range is limited to physical keys, without involvement in lock mechanics or integrated security solutions.

In terms of tools used

Keysmith unlocking a residential door using a traditional key (Source: iStock)

Locksmiths work with advanced tools for both mechanical and electronic systems. Their kits often include precision lock-picking sets, rekeying tools, transponder key programmers, and smart lock configurators. Many also carry mobile key-cutting machines that handle high-security and vehicle keys, allowing them to complete complex jobs on-site.

Keysmiths, in contrast, use basic key duplication equipment—typically manual or automatic key-cutting machines designed for standard keys like those used in homes or padlocks. Some also use impression tools to create new keys without an original, but their toolset is limited to conventional key shaping and cutting.

In terms of emergency response

Locksmith-installed smart lock system with keypad access on a modern door (Source: iStock)

Keysmiths generally operate during standard business hours from fixed locations, such as kiosks or hardware shops. Their services are not designed for time-sensitive situations, and they are not equipped to provide on-site assistance for issues like lockouts or broken keys.

Locksmiths, by contrast, are equipped for urgent response. Many offer 24/7 mobile services and can assist with emergencies involving homes, vehicles, or commercial properties. With the tools and training to handle on-the-spot solutions, they’re often able to arrive within the hour and resolve access-related problems.

In terms of pricing

Keysmiths are generally the more budget-friendly option, with prices ranging from $5 to $23 for standard key duplication. Their lower costs reflect the simplicity of their services, which typically involve straightforward, in-shop key cutting for homes, padlocks, and cabinets.

Locksmiths, on the other hand, offer a broader and more complex range of services, often at higher rates. Pricing depends on the task and can range from $51 to $303. Factors like emergency response, travel time, and service complexity (e.g., transponder key programming or lock repair) can significantly influence the final cost.

Get help fast: Find a locksmith or keysmith near you on Airtasker

Whether it’s cutting a spare key or unlocking a tricky door, getting the right expert matters. A keysmith is perfect for simple key needs, while a locksmith is your go-to for anything more complex.

Need help now? Post a task on Airtasker and connect with local professionals who can do the job quickly and reliably.