Fan vs air conditioner: Which should you get for your home?

When the summer heat rolls in, keeping your home and yourself cool becomes a top priority. With many options available, how do you choose the best way to beat the heat? You’re more likely to choose between a fan vs air conditioner.

In this guide, we’ll compare the differences between fans and air conditioners to help you decide the best fit for your home. Whether you’re looking to save money or maximise comfort, we’ll break down everything you need to know to make an informed decision.

How does a fan work?

Black electric fan blowing air near a sunny window in a home interior (Source: iStock)

Fans use an electric motor to spin blades, creating airflow that moves air across your skin. This airflow doesn’t lower the room temperature, but it helps you feel cooler by speeding up sweat evaporation, which draws heat away from your body. 

Fans also improve air circulation by circulating warm, stale air throughout a room and making fresher air flow in from other areas or outside.

How does an air conditioner work?

Outdoor unit of a split air conditioner installed on a home’s exterior for efficient cooling (Source: iStock)

An air conditioner cools a space by removing heat from indoor air and releasing it outside, thereby lowering the room temperature. It does this using a closed refrigerant cycle that absorbs heat indoors and expels it outdoors. 

Warm air passes over the evaporator coil, where the refrigerant absorbs heat and turns into a gas. This gas is compressed and then sent to the condenser coil outside. The heat is released and the refrigerant returns to a liquid state, allowing the cycle to repeat. 

In the process, air conditioners also reduce humidity, as moisture condenses on the evaporator coil. A thermostat controls the system to maintain a set temperature. 

Air conditioner vs fan: Which is better for your needs?

While each cooling solution has its pros and cons, choosing between fans versus air conditioning units will depend on your specific needs or preferences.

In terms of variety

Spinning ceiling fan with metal finish and pull chains for speed control (Source: iStock)

Fans are available in a range of styles designed for different spaces and use cases, from small desk fans to ceiling and pedestal fans for larger rooms.

Air conditioners also come in multiple types, offering various levels of cooling power and coverage. Options include window and portable units for single rooms, split systems for fixed room cooling, and ducted or ductless systems designed to cool larger areas or entire homes.

In terms of cost

Fans have a low upfront cost, with prices varying by size, type, and features. They’re generally inexpensive to run, and repairs—such as for pedestal or ceiling fans—are usually affordable.

Air conditioners are more expensive, particularly split and ducted systems. They also use much more electricity than fans, which leads to higher ongoing energy costs, especially during warmer months.

In terms of installation ease

Most fans are quick and easy to set up. Desk, table, pedestal, and tower fans may require minimal assembly and can be used straight away. Ceiling and wall-mounted fans involve more work and may require electrical wiring, but installation is relatively simple for basic DIY jobs.

AC installation varies by system type. Window and portable units are straightforward to install, though they need proper window fitting or venting. Split and ducted air conditioning systems are more complex and typically require professional installation.

In terms of cooling effectiveness

Classic table fan providing a cool breeze next to a cosy reading setup (Source: iStock)

Air conditioners actively cool a space by removing heat and humidity from the air, which lowers the actual room temperature. This makes them effective in very hot or humid conditions and suitable for cooling single rooms or entire homes, depending on the system. They also allow precise temperature control.

Unfortunately, fans don’t reduce room temperature. Instead, they create airflow that helps you feel cooler by speeding up sweat evaporation. This works well in mild to moderate heat but becomes less effective in very hot conditions, as fans only move existing air rather than cooling it.

In terms of air quality control

Most fans, such as ceiling fans, desk fans, and stand fans, generally do not provide air quality control. They simply circulate air but do not filter or purify it. However, some modern tower fans may include features that improve air quality. 

On the other hand, air conditioning systems often include air filters that can help remove dust, allergens, and other particles, improving indoor air quality.

In terms of noise level

Most fans, such as stand fans and ceiling fans, operate with minimal noise. This makes fans suitable for environments where low noise levels are important, such as bedrooms or offices. However, the noise level can vary depending on your fan’s speed and type, with some larger or high-powered fans producing more noticeable sound.

Meanwhile, air conditioners, particularly window units and portable models, tend to be noisier. They produce a noticeable hum due to the compressor and other moving parts. Central air systems and split systems are typically quieter inside the home since the noisy components are located outside, but they still generate background noise when in use.

In terms of maintenance

AC cleaning in progress with water spray removing dust from the unit (Source: iStock)

Fans require only regular dusting, and occasional cleaning is usually sufficient. Some components may need lubrication from time to time, but overall, maintenance is minimal.

Conversely, air conditioners require regular filter cleaning or changes, coil cleaning, occasional refrigerant top-ups, and even draining system cleaning. This makes air conditioner maintenance and cleaning more time-consuming. The same goes for AC repair services, should anything break or need fixing.

Request electrician services on Airtasker

Whether you need wiring for a new ceiling fan, installation of a split system, or general electrical work, Airtasker connects you with qualified electricians in your area through our platform. 

It’s easy! You can post a task in minutes and receive offers from nearby, qualified electricians. You’ll be able to compare prices, read reviews, and check ratings before choosing the right Tasker for the job.

Once you’ve booked, simply agree on a time that suits you and let a trusted professional handle the rest.