The best lash treatments compared: Lift and tint vs. extensions

Looking to make your eyes stand out? Whether you want a soft, natural curl or a bold, head-turning look, choosing between a lash lift and tint vs. extensions can feel overwhelming. While both treatments enhance your eye shape and lashes, they offer different results and benefits.

In this guide, we break down what sets each option apart. From the application process to maintenance, longevity, and overall upkeep, here’s everything you need to know about a lash tint and lift vs extensions so you can decide which is right for you.

What is a lash lift and tint?

Performing a semi-permanent lash lift procedure (Source: iStock)

A lash lift and tint is a semi-permanent lash treatment that involves applying chemical mixtures to curl and lift natural eyelashes upward, combined with tinting to darken their color. The treatment generally lasts four to six weeks with minimal maintenance required.

The chemical solutions consist of two components: a perming solution that softens the lashes to curl them, and a setting lotion that locks and sets the lashes into their newly curled shape. The tint enhances the lash color naturally, so you don’t need to resort to applying eye makeup every day.

What are lash extensions? 

Applying individual lash extensions in-salon (Source: iStock)

Lash extensions are a non-invasive procedure that helps your eyelashes appear longer, thicker, and fuller. This treatment saves you the hassle of applying false lashes daily. Regardless of whether you have sparse lashes or normal lashes, lash extensions suit everyone.

The process involves a lash technician applying an adhesive to the base of your natural eyelashes, then attaching synthetic extensions to the root of each individual lash. Because the eyelash extensions are bonded to your lashes, they’ll gradually wear off as your natural hair grows.

Lash lift or extensions: What are their key differences?

If you’re set on enriching the look of your natural lashes but have difficulty choosing between a lash lift or extensions, don’t worry. The list below rounds up their key differences to help you make an informed decision.

In terms of the application process

Specialist tools used for detailed lash application (Source: iStock)

A lash lift and tint requires applying a chemical perm solution to naturally curl your lashes upward, followed by a tint to darken the color. This entire process usually takes less than an hour. While DIY kits are available online, as you’re dealing with chemical solutions, it’s best to visit a trained beautician or makeup artist who can identify the most suitable products for your eyes.

In contrast, extensions take longer, as synthetic lashes must be carefully glued to each individual lash with an adhesive to create a more dramatic effect. Afterward, the extensions are trimmed to suit your eye shape, ensuring they’re comfortable to wear. This process can take between one and three hours, so it’s best done by a trained professional to ensure hygiene, safety, and quality results.

In terms of look and appearance

Lash extensions give you the appearance of fuller, longer, and thicker lashes, creating a bold, dramatic look that makes your eyes stand out. Through lash mapping, you can customize the length of your extensions, whether you prefer a natural, dramatic, or fluttery style. A lash technician at your local salon can also recommend additional options, depending on what they believe best suits your eye shape.

Unlike lash extensions, eyelash lifts and tints enhance your natural lashes using chemical lifting solutions. This option is ideal for those who prefer a polished, everyday look. You also don’t have to worry about extensions falling off or needing frequent maintenance. However, a lash lift on short lashes may not deliver noticeable length, as it can’t extend lashes beyond their natural length.

In terms of lifespan

Curled lashes following a successful procedure (Source: iStock)

How long does an eyelash tint last? Remember that an eyelash lift and tint doesn’t require refills, so results can last between six and eight weeks. However, this depends on the natural growth cycle of your eyelashes, as the curl gradually fades as your lashes grow out. Since this procedure doesn’t involve applying synthetic lashes on top of your natural ones, minimal maintenance is required, whether it’s an eyelash lift or an eyelash perm.

In comparison, lash extensions have a shorter lifespan, meaning regular refills are needed every two to three weeks. The frequency of refills depends on how often you rub your eyes, how you live your day-to-day life, and how well you care for your lashes. Keeping up with your appointments is essential to maintain a full, polished look. Skipping refills can lead to noticeable gaps and a thinner-looking lash line.

In terms of maintenance

When it comes to upkeep, lash lifts are relatively low maintenance. The most important stage is the aftercare period during the first 24 to 48 hours following treatment, when you should avoid water, steam, and eye makeup. Because this treatment enhances your natural eyelashes, there’s no need for daily brushing or special products. Lash lifts and tints can last up to eight weeks, meaning fewer visits to your lash artist.

Lash extensions, on the other hand, require more ongoing care. Gentle daily brushing helps prevent tangling, and you’ll need to avoid rubbing your eyes to minimize damage. Regular maintenance is also necessary to prevent gaps or sparse areas in the lash line. To maintain a full set and your desired length and volume, appointments with a lash technician are typically needed every two to three weeks.

In terms of allergic reactions

Technician applying synthetic lash extensions (Source: iStock)

Allergic reactions are uncommon with both treatments, but they’re not impossible. The chemical solutions used in eyelash-perming lifts and tints contain dyes and other ingredients that may trigger sensitivities in some individuals. Being aware of the ingredients used is important, as reactions can occur if you’re sensitive to certain dyes or chemicals. Symptoms may include redness, swelling, or irritation around the eyes.

With lash extensions, allergic reactions may occur due to the adhesive used during application. Ingredients such as cyanoacrylate and carbon black pigments can sometimes cause reactions, including redness or swelling around the eyes. To minimize risk, it’s recommended to carry out a patch test before proceeding with a full set.

In terms of cost

Upfront, lash extensions are generally more expensive than lash lifts due to the initial application and the need for regular refills. The cost of eyelash extensions varies depending on the type of set selected. Full sets typically range from $125 to $300, half sets average around $70, and refills usually cost between $70 and $90.

In comparison, eyelash lifts and tints are more affordable, with prices commonly ranging from $75 to $150. Costs can vary based on your location, the salon, and the lash technician’s experience. If you naturally have dark lashes, you may choose to skip the tint to help reduce the overall cost.

Get the dream eye look

Discover the right treatment to achieve your dream eye look today. Now that you understand the key differences, ask yourself two simple questions: how much time can you realistically commit to upkeep, and how much are you willing to spend? Your answers will help guide you to the treatment that suits you best.

When you’re ready to book, Airtasker helps you find experienced lash extension and lash lifting specialists near you. With verified reviews and transparent quotes, you can confidently hire the right professional at your preferred schedule.